Nomination Clarifications and Queries #2

[candyheartsex]

All nominations not under discussion here have been reviewed! I'll continue cleaning up the tagset to remove duplicates, disambiguate wandering tags, and make corrections, but there shouldn't be any more major additions. Thanks to everyone for being immensely helpful in catching problems!

Merging

The Suicide Squad movies --> DCEU
Monstrous Regiment - Terry Pratchett --> Discworld - Terry Pratchett
Danganronpa: Trigger Happy Havoc --> Dangan Ronpa Series
Hawkeye (Comics) --> Marvel (Comics) with disambiguation

Clarifications

The Thursday Murder Club Series - Richard Osman
Wylding Hall - Elizabeth Hand

Both of these were nominated with some individual characters and/or places rather than relationships. I've approved the nomination of groups in both cases, but nominators, do you have any further relationships you'd like to add?

Crossover nominations between different eras of Doctor Who, or between Doctor Who and Torchwood, have generally been approved under Crossover Fandom, with each character disambiguated under their respective series. (Cameos complicate this, so let me know if your nomination is affected by that and you'd prefer the relationship to appear in a different fandom/subfandom.)

All Media Types

If you nominated any of the following fandoms and actually want a specific version of the canon, please comment here. (The AMT nomination will stay, but your preferred version can be added as a separate fandom.) If not, I'll assume they're fine and leave these as they are:

Shawshank Redemption - All Media Types
Jesus Christ Superstar - All Media Types
Addams Family - All Media Types
Beetlejuice - All Media Types
Master and Commander - All Media Types
Newsies - All Media Types
Ouran High School Host Club - All Media Types

Questions

1. Nominations for Pokemon - All Media Types have been approved under Pokemon (Main Video Game Series), except Nobori | Ingo & Teru | Rei, which is in Pokemon Legends: Arceus. Nominator(s), would you like this also listed under Main Video Game Series, or would you like alternate versions of any of your Pokemon nominations added?

2. Nominator for The Amazing Spider-Man (Movies) RPF, your nominations were for movie characters rather than the actors. Did you want RPF, or should these nominations be under the movie itself?

3. Lord of the Rings (Movies) nomination for Aragorn/Halbarad--I can't find verification that Halbarad appeared in the films. Did you mean this to appear under the book series?

4. Batter My Heart Three Person’d God - John Donne: Nominator, I've approved this relationship as Three-Person'd God/Poetic Speaker to use the name(s) most apparent in the text. Does this work as a simplified label?

5. Any Ship I've Liked: Would "Any Fandom I've Requested or Created For" work as the fandom here? Any/Any or Creator's Choice of Relationship could be the ships.

6. Nominator(s) for The Doctor & Donna Noble and The Doctor & Martha Jones, do you have specific iterations of the Doctor in mind, or would you like it to be Any Doctor & Donna and/or Any Doctor & Martha?

7. Crossover nominators:

Long Long Man (Sakeru Gum Commercials)/Willy Wonka -- Can you specify what canon you want for Willy Wonka?
Nico di Angelo & Jason Todd -- Can you specify what canon you want for Jason Todd?
Peter Parker (Spider-Man - Webb)/Johnny Storm -- Can you specify what canon you want for Johnny Storm?

8. Watchmen - All Media Types: Nominations have been approved under the comics. Nominator(s), do you want the comics versions? If not, would you prefer having the movie added as a fandom or to stick with All Media Types?

9. X-Men (Movieverse): Nominator(s), please specify whether you want the Original Timeline Movies or the Alternate Timeline Movies for the following relationships:

John Allerdyce & Bobby Drake & Jubilation Lee & Kitty Pryde & Piotr Rasputin & Rogue
John Allerdyce/Bobby Drake/Rogue
John Allerdyce/Rogue
Kitty Pryde & Rogue & Jubilation Lee
Logan & Rogue
Rogue & Charles Xavier
Rogue & Hank McCoy
Rogue & Jean Grey & Ooro Munroe
Rogue & Scott Summers

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Couple of duplicates:

The Sandman (TV 2022)
The Corinthian/Dream of the Endless (Sandman TV)
The Corinthian/Dream of the Endless | Morpheus (Sandman TV)

DCU (Comics)
Jason Todd/Tim Drake (DCU)
Tim Drake/Jason Todd (DCU)

[candyheartsex]

Duplicates deleted, thanks!

[rebecca2525]

Spotted another duplicate:

Agatha Christie's Poirot (TV):

Arthur Hastings/Hercule Poirot (AC's Poirot)
Arthur Hastings/Hercule Poirot (Poirot TV)

[candyheartsex]

Duplicate deleted, thanks!

[(Anonymous)]

Found a wandering tag

This should be under Crossovers but wandered into Untitled Goose Game:

Goat (Goat Simulator) & Goose (Untitled Goose Game)

[candyheartsex]

Ah, thank you! Fixed. (That's the second Untitled Goose Game-related tag that's been wandering. It really is a horrible goose.)

[zdenka]

Babylon 5 is currently under 3 overlapping fandoms: Babylon 5 (TV 1993), Babylon 5 & Related Fandoms, and Babylon 5: Legend of the Rangers. To the best of my knowledge, all the relationships currently under B5&RF would fit under Babylon 5 (TV 1993). If the nominator(s) agree, would it make sense to move the noms currently under B5&RF to Babylon 5 (TV 1993)?

(Not a nominator for this fandom, but considering requesting it, and it would be easier if the B5 people were all in the same place.)

[rebecca2525]

I was wondering about this, too. (Not a nominator either.) For "Alfred Bester & Sandoval Bey", it seems that Sandoval Bey comes from a tie in novel and an unfilmed Crusade episode, so the Related Fandoms tag would make more sense? But for the others, yeah.

[candyheartsex]

Combining some of these makes sense to me! I'll put up a post today to see if the nominator(s) have any objections, and if not, I'll move all the Babylon 5 & Related Fandoms nominations (except for Alfred Bester & Sandova Bey) under Babylon 5 (TV 1993).

[(Anonymous)]

Spotted a duplicate under Promare (2019):
Lio Fotia/Galo Thymos (Promare)
Lio Fotia/Galo Thymos

And "Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood & Manga" seems to have wandered under the Cartoons, Comics & Graphic Novels umbrella

[candyheartsex]

Duplicate deleted, thanks!

Unfortunately, I can't do anything about AO3's categorization of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood & Manga, so it'll keep appearing under multiple categories.

[(Anonymous)]

I tried to nominate individuals in the case of Wylding Hall and Thursday Murder Club but the archive wouldn't let me so I resorted to a group nomination. I can give individual characters if that's better for noms?

[candyheartsex]

You can't nominate solo characters, but if you have any relationships you'd like to add, like Character A & Character B, or Character B/Character C, etc., you can put them here, and I'll add them to the tagset.

[(Anonymous)]

Ah, the group nominations are fine thank you!

[marquisguyun]

Found a duplicate! In 卿卿日常 | New Life Begins (TV)

Li Wei/Yin Zheng (NLB)
Yin Zheng/Li Wei (NLB)

[candyheartsex]

Fixed, thanks!

X-Men Nominator here

[(Anonymous)]

Could all listed X-Men relationships be categorized under the Original Movie Timeline, please? Sorry for the confusion!

Re: X-Men Nominator here

[candyheartsex]

Done, thanks!

Duplicate

[(Anonymous)]

I noticed the tagset has both Shy & Lonely Prince/Court Jester & Court Jester/Shy & Lonely Prince in it under OW.

Re: Duplicate

[candyheartsex]

Fixed, thanks!

[(Anonymous)]

Looks like Persona 3 has both Kirijo Mitsuru/Takeba Yukari (P3) and Kirijo Mitsuru/Takeba Yukari (Persona 3), and Ace Attorney has both Ayasato Chihiro | Mia Fey/Kaminogi Souryuu | Diego Armando (Ace Attorney) and Diego Armando/Mia Fey (AA) as well as Karuma Mei | Franziska von Karma & Mitsurugi Reiji | Miles Edgeworth (AA) and Karuma Mei | Franziska von Karma & Mitsurugi Reiji | Miles Edgeworth (Ace Attorney).

[candyheartsex]

Fixed, thanks!

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! I'm not the nominator, but since "Any Fandom I've Requested or Created For" was added to the tagset: are there rules pertaining to it? Are we allowed to DNW certain fandoms/ships?

[candyheartsex]

Yes, you can DNW particular fandoms and ships even with that request. There's no hard-and-fast rule about how many is too many, aside from the general rule that you can't use DNWs to box your author into producing a very specific work. As long as your potential creator still has some choices, it's fine to DNW canons/ships.

[teddyaltman]

Only just saw this, sorry I'm late! I was the person who nominated Nico & Jason, and Peter/Johnny.

Jason Todd would just be DCU Comics, and Johnny Storm would be Fantastic Four (2015) which I wasn't sure how to disambiguate. Hope it isn't too late to squeeze those into the tagset!

[candyheartsex]

Thanks for clarifying! I've added those to the tagset.